1728 Montauk Highway Water Mill, NY
$ 4,995,000
Property Attributes
  • MLS#3298332
  • TypeMulti-Family
  • CountySUFFOLK
  • CityWater Mill
  • Area31
  • Zip11976
  • StyleEstate
  • Year Built1875
  • Taxes$ 6955
  • Price$ 4,995,000
  • Bedrooms6
  • Full Bathrooms4
  • Half Bathrooms0
  • Lot Size4.56 Acres
Listing Provided Courtesy Of:
Saundra C Parola | William F LeMaire III with Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton
Data Source:
OneKey MLS
Property Description

A truly once in a lifetime opportunity, this rare 4.5-acre estate in the heart of the Hamptons is an important property in a very desirable location. The expansive gated compound in Water Mill is comprised of a classic Greek Revival main house, separate guest house, pool and two detached garage buildings, all enveloped by glorious landscaping. Originally built in 1875, the 4,382 sf main house conveys traditional elegance, with well-proportioned principal rooms and sophisticated details throughout. Fully remodeled in 2001, the house blends the classic architectural style of historic Hamptons estates with the finest amenities and materials of today. The first floor features a formal living room with fireplace, large family room, formal dining room, guest bedroom and a spacious eat-in kitchen that opens to a house-length sun deck. Front and back stairs lead to the second floor, there are 3 guest bedrooms and a master suite with private balcony.

Price History
3/26/2021 Listed $4,995,000

General Features

Architectural Style Estate
Buildingareaunits Square Feet
Construction Materials Frame, Cedar, Shake Siding
Cooling Central Air
Elementary School District Southampton
Garage Spaces 4.00
Garage Y/N Yes
Heating Natural Gas, Baseboard
High School District Southampton
Hot Water Gas Stand Alone
Levels 2.00
Middle/Junior School District Southampton
Numberofheatingzones 5
Numberofkitchens 2
Parking Features Private, Detached, 4+ Car Detached
Property SubType Multi Family
Property Type Residential Income
PropertyCondition Excellent
Sewer Cesspool
Tax Annual Amount 6955.68
Total Rooms 12
Total Units 2

Interior Features

Air Conditioning Y/N Yes
Fireplace Y/N Yes
Total Fireplaces 2

Exterior Features

Lot Dimensions 4.56 Acres
Lot Size Acres 4.5600
Lot Size Area 4.5600
Lot Size Source Other
Lot Size Square Feet 198634.00
Lot Size Units Acres


  • Foreclosure
  • Views
  • Short Sale
  • New Construction
  • Adult 55+
  • Lease To Own
  • No HOA Fees
  • Furnished
  • Master On Main
  • Air Conditioning
  • Seller Finance
  • Green
  • Fixer Upper
  • Horse
  • Golf
  • Fireplace
  • Deck
  • Garage
  • Basement
  • Pool

Property vs Zip Code Average in 11976

AVG $6,955
AVG 60
Year Built
AVG 1875

Looking for a more comfortable experience?

Download our mobile app for a personalized browsing experience.

Areas We Cover

Fair Housing Icon NY Fair Housing Notice